NO ACTION ON PROTESTERS

Demonstration against use of 'allah' should be held in restricted compounds, says PM
Thursday, January 7th, 2010 15:05:00

 

naijb

HALE AND HEARTY: Najib gets his blood pressure checked after he opened the 1Malaysia clinic in pantai Dalam. Pic: SHAHIR OMAR

 

KUALA LUMPUR: No action will be taken against those planning demonstrations over a High Court ruling allowing the use of the word "allah" by the Catholic weekly Herald.

Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak said it is okay, as long as the protests were held within restricted premises and compounds.

Najib said this after launching the much-awaited 1Malaysia Community Clinic in Kampung Kerinchi this morning.

He said Muslim groups were free to protest and express their views on the issue as long as it did not spill over into something more serious.

"We hope the protests will not spill over. Better still, if the protest is under control," he said, adding the authorities "cannot stop people from gathering at mosques and protesting there".

Asked about the government's stand on last week's Kuala Lumpur High Court ruling that allowed the Catholic church to use the word "allah" in the Herald, Najib said the Cabinet had decided to allow the process of the court to take place.

"The government is appealing the ruling and, for the moment, we will leave it at that."

The prime minister was responding to reports that Muslim Youth Movement (Abim) and the National Association of Muslim Students (PKPIM) were planning to protest nationwide tomorrow against the court's decision.

After the launch, Najib told reporters that medical practitioners need not worry that their turf being usurped with the opening of 50 community clinics nationwide under the 1Malaysia programme for the rakyat.

"There is nothing to worry. We are only providing basic service."

The Malaysian Medical Association had earlier said that the 1Malaysia clinics would affect the country's standard of medical service.

He also told reporters that the government had spent RM10 million to open some 50 clinics nationwide. "We will evaluate the performance of the clinics and decide if we want to open more."

At the launch, Najib said the clinics were the government's promise to the low-income group in urban areas under the "people first" concept when announcing the 2010 Budget.

"With the opening of these clinics in the neighbourhood, people can save their travelling time and also get early treatment."

Health Minister Datuk Sri Liow Tiong Lai said the clinic would be open from 10am to 10pm daily and manned by a nurse, an attendant and supporting staff .

'Let us all keep harmony'

The issue of the exclusivity of the word 'allah' is a "big deal" among the country's Muslims and should be looked at in the Malaysian context, says Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Jamil Khir Baharom.

The minister who is in charge of Islamic affairs said the usage of the word 'allah' could be categorised as being specific to the Muslims.

"From the day we are born to the day we die, the name 'allah' has always accompanied us and is recognised as a name we use to call our God.

"This issue is a big deal and it isn't enough for the court to make the decision on its usage. Instead, we should analyse the history of Islam in this country. It has been rooted within us that Allah refers to the God of Muslims.

"Since non-Muslims have never had any issue with not using the word 'allah' before, they should just continue to do so," said Jamil Khir at a media conference on the Zakat Collection Centre's (PPZ) 2009 tithe collection at Dataran Shamelin Perkasa, Taman Shamelin Perkasa, this morning.

Earlier, he said what was important was not who wins or who has the right to use the word 'allah'.

"What's important is keeping the harmony between Muslims and non-Muslims."

On the PPZ's 2009 tithe collection, Jamil Khir said the Federal Territories Islamic Religious Council's (Mawi) tithe collection agency collected RM242 million compared with RM206 million in 2008.

The number of tithe contributers has also increased from 67,672 in 2008 to 78,820 last year.

He said one of the factors of the contribution was the thohir scheme which allows tithe payments through salary deductions.

Last year's collection saw 68 per cent of the tithe contributers using the scheme, paying RM142 million of the total amount.

For this year, PPZ is aiming to collect RM250 million.

Comments

Road Warrior wants to see protests on the roads while the PM and police wants protests and demos confined in controlled areas. Only someone with a brain the size of a pea would know which one will lead to probable violence, damages and unneccessary hardships to the general public. Islam is Ad Din - the way of life and politics is part of Islam as what I was made to understand by by driver, a kind Haji from Kelantan and a chinese muslim convert and a religious teacher hired by my childrens' international school to provide understanding of islam here. There are millions of malaysians here of different religious, cultural and language background but sadly, there are still the few who are blind in their hearts so much so that they will damage houses of prayers, instigate others via blogs and silly comments, disrespect to sensitive issues pertaining to religions etc etc Still, Malaysia is a wonderful place to work and live.

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, January 14th, 2010.
Putting words into a person's mouth is a kind of slander... did your religion teach you to do that? Did I say I want to see street demos? Tak tau bacakah? Protest even in a confine area is not good because people gets provocative and the whole world can see. To those who can read please read properly first.

Submitted by Road Warrior on Monday, January 18th, 2010.
What's wrong with protests held in mosques? It was a brilliant idea from your PM that the muslims hold their protests within the compound of the mosques instead of going into the streets like hooligans...taunting police and defying orders. My family and a few other expat families were there when the indians protested in the streets and we heard the police giving orders several times before initiating actions. Your police INDEED gave a lot of warnings and orders before they did what they are trained for! Is there someone here suggesting that your police send in dogs and anti riot police into the compounds of your mosque? Come on Malaysians - wake up to common sense and strip away your anti establishment and racist remarks and this racist remarks comes from ALL races...not just the dominant malays or the minority chinese, indians, sikhs etc etc. There isnt any perfect country - its only perfect because there is a draconian government over it!

Submitted by Anonymous on Thursday, January 14th, 2010.
Can Christians also hold protest against church attack and provocation by Muslims gathered for protest last Friday? You will see what happens next! That will show what kind of standards use by the government who obviously did a blunder last Friday. Those who want to go against court justice by using such measures are the same people that will rejoice and speak of 'justice' if the decision is in favour of them... hypocrites. As for some of the politicians... they just taking advantage of the situation for their own agenda. Are religious places like mosques a place for such activities... it is an insult.

Submitted by Road Warrior on Wednesday, January 13th, 2010.
How do you know the attackers are Muslims? Do you have any information about the attackers? If you do then please do yourselves a favor by assisting the police in their investigation. Or else don't speak of matters that you don't know and still under investigation by the police. No offense. Until the investigation is over please be fair in your comment about Muslims attacking other religions place of worship because true Muslim never do that. By all means please have your own demonstration, but in doing that, please follow all the rules provided by our law like those who protested last Friday. Without troubles and hassles.

Submitted by MyMalaya on Thursday, January 14th, 2010.
Please read the mail properly before talking without thinking! I did not say the attackers were Muslims but the provocators were. My sentence has two separate points inside. Read first my friend if you are unclear ask for clarification. Faham tak?

Submitted by Road Warrior on Monday, January 18th, 2010.
The protest last Friday was one that is peaceful and only inside the mosque compound. It didn't spill outside the mosque as intended by the organizer. Those who said this is double standard should reflect on previous protests which result in damage of properties, traffic jams, without permit etc. My salute to those who came out to defend their stand in this issue.

Submitted by MyMalaya on Monday, January 11th, 2010.
2 set of laws for one nation!! There is n cure for mental retardation. What has become of my malaysia, negaraku?

Submitted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
If we respect one another... we should also realize that Islam does not have the sole ownership of the word 'Allah' even on the birth place of that religion.

Submitted by Road Warrior on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
1 MALAYSIA 2 STANDARD

Submitted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
FYI: kelantan state song, selamat sultan, also has the word "allah" in it. yet, u see muslims & non-muslims still lives so harmoniously together back there. Lanjutkan usia Al-Sultan kami Sultan Kelantan raja ikrami Aman sentosa Tuhan sirami Kekal memerintah kami Kasih dan taat setia disembahkan Keriangan diucapkan Segala kebesaran Allah cucurkan Bertambah kemuliaan

Submitted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
Muslims and Christians ARE indeed living peaceful here. Muslims will even visit Christians if tomorrow was going to be Xmas. And Christians would even provided HALAL food for their muslim visitors - you would not see this in the west!!!! My expat family and I were walking around Little India and Bukit Bintang areas and one would hardly noticed if there was any religious tensions!!!! That's the beauty of Malaysia and Malaysians generally. The Herald's leaders should have discussed the matter of persuing the word ALLAH with the muslim religious first instead of going to the courts as the fundamental issue here is RESPECT. After all, the leader of The Herald is a Tan Sri and a learned man! For every action, there is a reaction but it's a very good thing that the Malaysian government particularly the police, has done a very good job. Malaysians should condemn not only the acts against churches effected but also against this learned Tan Sri leader of The Herald - from our 8 years' of living here, we have noticed that malay muslims are very courteous unlike their fellow muslims across the straits! This is another good test for Malaysia and Malaysians - keep on supporting and respecting each other for this is the strength of MALAYSIA!

Submitted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
Demonstration should never be allowed!

Submitted by alantanblog on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
there are differences of opinion on the use of "allah" even among the various christian denominations and still they insist on using allah only in their malay version of their catholis hereld. Can you images how silly they get ... it is alright is they have been worng about allah in their english publications. Why insist on the use in the malay version.What about the english vsrsion.

Submitted by june on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
if you fellas had any brain you would without raising a fuss take it that the PM meant that it was okay to protest at designated places and not on the streets. The muslims were planning to hold demo at mosques and other enclosed areas not taking to the streets. It is amazing how people can find points of argument for their bais leaning.When anyone say that protest and demos are bad they point to the west and say it is part of the democratic way and as a civil right. But when one allows for protest they turn around and say the government is not taking care of public peace etc. How do you deal with such morons.

Submitted by rasid on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
malaysia boleh man.. !!!!! MALAYSIA BOLEH !!!!!

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
MINISTERS COME AND MINISTERS GO. THEY ALWAYS LEAVE BEHIND THE S*** BEFORE THEY GO. MALAYSIA BOLIH MANN !!! MALAYSIA BOLIH !!!

Submitted by ooi on Sunday, January 10th, 2010.
What if the "Christians" hold demonstration to "PROTEST THE BURNING OF THEIR CHURCH" by others??? Is it "STILL OKAY" ? We are MALAYSIAN, we're not RACIST or RELIGIOUS EXTREMIST, if we (RAKYAT) don't know how to behave, it is the duty of our LEADERS to guide and teach. Leaders should practice FAIRNESS when judging a situation. A good LEADER will practice that. I believe "ONLY TRUE MALAYSIANS ARE PEACE LOVING" - If you are MALAYSIAN, do you wish for PEACE?

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
Just do & don't talk empty. Everybody has own rights. After you did and government react, now we know how it looks like. Then it will fair to give statements.

Submitted by Ali on Monday, January 11th, 2010.
I am very scared for the future of this country. Ever since I was in Shah Alam continuing my studies, I was called "infidel/orang kafir/orang asli tinggal atas pokok" just because I am not a Muslim in a certain public university.As far as I can remember living in Sarawak, none of my Muslims friend EVER called me that! If the Muslims Malays of Sarawak can tolerate other communities, why couldnt' the Muslims in West Malaysia?

Submitted by OrangAsliGirl on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
I understand how you feel. If I were you I feel the same.Well, concentrate on your study and do your best to ignore those ppl. Finish your study and move to another nice state to work.You will overcome all this.Believe me.good luck.

Submitted by ooi on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
I have been residing in Kuala Lumpur for almost 20 years now. I faced the same problem when i was a student in Shah Alam. Those that said that to you, are like everybody who's young, always anxious and easily influenced in the negative ways. After so many years, now, we understand things better, and we have taken a moderate stance on almost everything. Some still remain in contact, and friends have never been better people. Pray to God, and ask for God's guidance for yourself, and for them. Things will be better. People change. I agree. Complete your studies and move on. Meanwhile, choose your friends. I am sure they are some, regardless of religion, who are ever willing to defend and help you. Trust me; I've been there.

Submitted by OldManNow on Wednesday, January 13th, 2010.
Crazy! It's crazy to say to one person that he can't say the word Allah, but to another he can. Crazy politics and crazy sheep for getting so wound up about it. So many sheep in Malaysia, indoctrinated into nonesense from birth.

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
This is so true. I'm working in the UK now. I am definitely looking for British citizenship and am going to help sponsor my relatives over here to leave this receding backwater country. Msia has nothing more to hold me back other than the food.

Submitted by Anonymous on Saturday, January 9th, 2010.
Now that trouble has started, who is responsible? I put the blame on Najib and Hisshamuddin.

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
The first thing after reading the news is to ask for a review of investments in Malaysia. I am sure everybody with money in Malaysia will do this and to try to reduce exposure. Nothing personal. Just business.

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
No action will be taken against those planning demonstrations? this A very effective method to close tourism. What did the tourist will feedback about Malaysia then?

Submitted by alantanblog on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
I hope that Muslim and Christians in this country will live in peace with each others. If we can do that in the past, why can't we continue with it. Why let this issue ruins what we have built in the past. Look at the Muslims and Christians in Sabah & Sarawak. The Christians there have been using the word Allah long ago but there is no problem with it. Can we learn something from them? I also hope that the Muslims leaders from UMNO, PAS , PKR and other NGO will come out with statements to calm their people down. When we have protest and demos, it wil make these ppl more emotional and such, things can go out of control. We are a civilised country and need to solve issues by law and order. Not anarchy.

Submitted by Francis on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
I foresee trouble.Belove citizens, dont let 1 man mistakes destroy everything. You decide urself.

Submitted by ooi on Friday, January 8th, 2010.
This 1Malaysia is all crap and double standards. Enuf said.

Submitted by Anonymous on Friday, January 8th, 2010.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Ground rules for posting comments:

1. No personal attacks.

2. No vulgar or discriminatory language.

3. If you do not follow these rules, we will remove your comment.

Disclaimer

In line with Malay Mail's tag-line "Your Voice", do use our comments service to express your opinions.

Kindly note that your comments will be moderated by Malay Mail before they are posted on this site. Malay Mail holds the sole right to publish or delete a comment that has been posted at its absolute discretion. Malay Mail will also not correct grammar or spelling mistakes that may exist in such comments.

We value your feedback and will strive to publish your comments as long as they:

* DO NOT contain anything which could be potentially libellous or defamatory.

* DO NOT contain foul language and are of a vulgar or abusive nature.

* DO NOT contain any offensive slurs.

* DO NOT contain religious or racial discrimination; and/or

* DO relate to the post that you are responding to.

Comments that breach the guidelines will be deleted/ignored or modified with immediate effect and with no prior notification to the author.

Also please note that the views expressed herewith are the sole responsibility of the visitor who submits each comment and not those of Malay Mail. Malay Mail does not bear the responsibility of any comment posted on the site. The publishing of such comment does not and is not to be understood that Malay Mail agrees with it, endorses it, or believes it to be correct and/or true.

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
11 + 9 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
Syndicate content

Disclaimer | Contact Us | Back to Top Δ

Contact our advertising team to place an advertisement in Malay Mail, Malay Mail Online, and Mail on Sunday.

Copyright 2009 Malay Mail Sdn. Bhd.